Are Take-Home Interview Tasks Still Worth It in the Age of AI?

Updated: Nov 13

Earlier this year, we experienced something that raised an important question about the way businesses assess marketing talent.
A candidate completed a take-home assessment for a Paid Social role. On paper, the work demonstrated the skills and understanding required.
But after starting the position, their practical performance didn't match what the assessment had suggested.
It got us thinking.
In an age where AI can generate campaign strategies, analyse performance data and produce convincing presentations in minutes, how much confidence should employers place in take-home assignments?
And are we still assessing the right things?
Why Do Employers Use Take-Home Tasks for Paid Social Roles?
Take-home tasks have long been a popular part of the recruitment process, particularly for performance marketing roles where practical ability matters just as much as experience on paper.
Traditionally, candidates would complete an assignment independently before presenting their findings in person to the hiring manager. This gave employers an opportunity to assess not only the quality of the work but also the candidate's ability to explain their thinking, defend their recommendations and respond to questions in real time.
Today, the process looks quite different. With remote and hybrid working becoming more established, particularly across DTC and consumer brands, many assessments are now completed and submitted entirely online. For fully remote positions, candidates may never present their work face-to-face.
For employers hiring a Paid Social Manager, these tasks are designed to assess skills that can be difficult to evaluate through a traditional interview.
They might ask candidates to:
- Analyse Meta Ads performance data and identify opportunities for improvement.
- Evaluate ROAS and CPA to demonstrate an understanding of campaign profitability and acquisition costs.
- Develop acquisition and creative testing strategies that support customer growth.
- Recommend budget allocations across campaigns, audiences and channels.
- Explain how they would scale paid social activity while maintaining efficiency.
The intention makes sense. Employers want reassurance that a candidate can apply their knowledge to realistic business challenges before trusting them with significant advertising budgets.
But there's a growing problem with this approach.
An impressive strategy document doesn't necessarily demonstrate someone's ability to execute that strategy.
And with AI tools now capable of analysing data, generating campaign recommendations and producing polished presentations in minutes, it's becoming increasingly difficult to distinguish between a candidate's genuine expertise and the quality of the work they've submitted.
The question for hiring managers is no longer simply whether a candidate can produce a convincing paid social strategy. It's whether they have the practical knowledge, commercial judgment and experience to deliver it when they're actually in the role.
What Should Employers Do Instead?
Rather than relying solely on take-home assignments, employers should consider assessments that reveal how candidates think, make decisions and respond to real-world challenges.
For Paid Social Managers, this could mean introducing a live campaign analysis, where candidates review performance data, identify potential issues and explain how they would improve results. A creative performance review can also reveal whether someone understands why certain ads outperform others and how they would approach the next round of testing.
Another option is a budget allocation scenario, asking candidates how they would distribute spend across campaigns and justify their decisions based on commercial objectives. Employers can also ask candidates to walk through a previous campaign, explaining their personal contribution, the challenges they faced and the results they achieved.
These approaches allow hiring managers to ask follow-up questions, challenge assumptions and see how candidates respond when presented with new information.
The goal isn't to catch candidates out or prevent them from using AI. It's to understand whether they have the practical experience and commercial judgment to turn a convincing strategy into measurable results.
To make this simple here are five Questions to Ask When Interviewing a Paid Social Manager:
1. Your Meta CPA has increased by 25% over the last month. How would you diagnose the problem?
2. How do you decide whether poor campaign performance is caused by creative, targeting or the landing page?
3. Tell us about a campaign that failed. What did you change?
4. How do you decide when to scale spend versus improve efficiency?
5. How are you using AI in your paid social workflow, and where do you avoid relying on it?
These are much more revealing than asking someone to produce a hypothetical 90-day strategy.
AI hasn't necessarily killed the take-home task. But it has made one thing increasingly clear: a convincing presentation isn't proof of practical ability.
Why References Still Matter
While practical assessments can reveal how candidates approach problems, speaking to previous employers can help establish how they've performed in a real working environment.
For Paid Social Managers, this means going beyond simply confirming employment history. Where possible, hiring managers should seek references from previous managers who can speak to the candidate's responsibilities, the advertising budgets they managed, how independently they worked and the results they delivered.
It's also worth asking how they responded when campaigns underperformed. After all, managing successful campaigns is one thing, but knowing how to diagnose problems and make commercially sound decisions when results decline is equally important.
References aren't a guarantee of future performance, and not every employer will provide detailed feedback. But when combined with practical assessments and scenario-based interviews, they offer another valuable perspective on a candidate's capabilities.
A polished presentation shows what someone can propose. Their track record helps demonstrate what they've actually delivered.
For founders and marketing leaders hiring performance talent, the question is no longer simply whether someone can build a strategy.
It's whether they can execute it, adapt it and deliver commercial results.
Hiring a Paid Social Manager, Performance Marketing Manager or Head of Growth? Acquire Search works with ambitious DTC and consumer brands to identify marketing talent with the experience to turn growth plans into measurable results.





Comments